The 15 Best Reeseās Flavors: Ranked and Reviewed
This article contains affiliate links. We may receive compensation if you make a purchase using one of these links at no additional cost to you. See our Disclaimers and Terms of Use for more information.

Reeseās isnāt just a candy brand. It produces the #1 best-selling candy in the United States, with annual revenue topping $3 billion. Itās also a candy with nearly a century of history under its belt.
The Reeseās story started in Hershey, Pennsylvania, when H.B. Reese, a former dairy farmer and shipping foreman for Milton Hershey, launched his own candy company in 1923. Five years later, Reese created his iconic peanut butter cup, which he originally sold for one cent each. The Hershey Company bought the H.B. Reese Candy Company in 1963. It wasnāt long before Reeseās Peanut Butter Cups were Hersheyās top seller.
Today, Reeseās treats are sold as cups, bars, sticks, dipped pretzels and seasonal shapes like bats, eggs, hearts, pumpkins and trees. The Reeseās candy line has plant-based and zero-sugar candies for those with special dietary requirements. And, if thatās not enough, the Reeseās name is on cereal, cake mix, ice cream and Oreo cookies, too.
š Key Takeaways
- Reeseās Peanut Butter Cups debuted in 1928 and sold for one cent each.
- Reeseās Pieces launched in 1978 and got a big sales boost after they appeared in the 1982 movie E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial.
- Recent Big Cup flavors include Caramel, Chocolate Lava, Marshmallow and Strawberry PB&J.
- Our top two picks are the original Reeseās Peanut Butter Cup and Reeseās Take 5.
Our Picks for the Best Reeseās Flavors
Our rankings start with Reeseās Peanut Butter Cups since theyāre the original and the brandās best seller. The rest follow in order of popularity, based on availability, shelf presence and fan buzz. Hershey doesnāt publish sales figures for individual Reeseās products. We include our honest review and a fun fact for all 15 treats.
1. Reeseās Peanut Butter Cups


Year Introduced: 1928
Ridged milk chocolate cups filled with sweet and salty peanut butter, Reeseās Peanut Butter Cups are the candy that launched the global brand. Itās a flavor combo that works, as Reeseās has been reminding us in commercials since the 1970s.
H.B. Reese first sold his self-named peanut butter cups in assortment boxes before selling them as standalone treats in the 1930s. Today, a standard orange pack has two peanut butter cups. Hershey sells other sizes including Minis, Miniatures, Big Cups and King Size packs with four cups.
Our Take: We grew up eating Reeseās Peanut Butter Cups, and the OG flavor is still our favorite. The ratio of chocolate to peanut butter is just right. To us, the combination of sweet milk chocolate and slightly gritty peanut butter is a winner.
Fun Fact
H.B. Reeseās original peanut butter cups cost one cent each.
2. Reeseās Pieces


Year Introduced: 1978
Reeseās Pieces are Reeseās answer to M&Mās. Both are crispy, bite-sized, filled candies. But unlike Peanut Butter M&Mās, Reeseās Pieces are chocolate-free. Also, Reeseās Pieces come in just three colors (brown, orange and yellow), while standard M&M colors are blue, brown, green, orange, red and yellow.
Our Take: We like eating Reeseās Pieces by the handful when weāre at the movie theater. Since theyāre chocolate-free, the bite-sized candies are less rich than peanut butter cups. We find Reeseās Pieces dangerously easy to keep eating until the box is empty.
Fun Fact
Sales for Reeseās Pieces jumped by more than 60% after the colorful candy appeared in the 1982 movie E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial.
3. Reeseās Miniatures


Year Introduced: 1978
Wrapped in gold foil and nestled in brown paper cups, Reeseās Miniatures are bite-size versions of the original peanut butter cup. Theyāre bigger than Reeseās Minis and individually wrapped, which makes them a Halloween staple. Hershey sells them in bags and holiday assortments.
Our Take: Unwrapping a Reeseās Miniature is part of the appeal. We peel off the foil, pull away the paper cup and pop them in our mouths whole. The bigger appeal is that the smaller cup tastes sweeter than the OG Reeseās Peanut Butter Cup and more peanut buttery than a Reeseās Mini.
Fun Fact
Reeseās Miniatures and Reeseās Pieces both debuted in 1978, which made it a big year for Reeseās fans.
4. Reeseās Minis


Year Introduced: 2011
Bite-size and unwrapped, Reeseās Minis deliver the classic peanut butter cup flavor in a pop-in-your-mouth format. Donāt confuse them with Reeseās Miniatures (see above), which are bigger and individually wrapped.
Our Take: Minis have a higher chocolate-to-peanut-butter ratio than all other Reeseās cup sizes. Thatās a plus or a minus depending on your priorities. For us, itās a plus.
Fun Fact
Despite their small size, Reeseās Minis arenāt appropriate for Halloween trick-or-treaters since theyāre not individually wrapped.
5. Reeseās Sticks


Year Introduced: 1998
Sold in pairs, Reeseās Sticks add crunch to the brandās classic flavor combo. These finger-sized, crispy wafer treats are layered with peanut butter and coated in milk chocolate.
Our Take: Reeseās Sticks remind us of Keeblerās Sugar Wafers but with a peanut butter flavor. We have a split decision on this flavor since one of us (Daryl) likes layered wafer cookies more than the other.
Fun Fact
Manner Neapolitan Wafers, the classic layered wafers from Vienna, date back to the 19th century.
6. Reeseās Take 5


Year Introduced: 2004
Reeseās Take 5 packs five elements into each bite: pretzel, caramel, peanuts, peanut butter and milk chocolate. The result is a layered candy bar thatās ideal any time a person literally wants to take five (i.e., take a break) with a sweet treat. Its original name, Take5, stood by itself as one word. Hershey added a space and rebranded the bar as Reeseās Take 5 in 2019.
Our Take: Reeseās Take 5 is the most complex candy in this guide. Salty pretzel, chewy caramel and crunchy peanuts show up in every tasty bite along with the expected milk chocolate and peanut butter.
Fun Fact
Reeseās Take 5 is sold as Reeseās Overload in the UK.
7. Reeseās White


Year Introduced: 2003
Reeseās White swaps milk chocolate for a white creme shell. The result is a candy that looks and tastes different yet similar to the original peanut butter cup.
Our Take: White creme makes this candy sweeter and less balanced than the original. This flavor gets a split decision since one of us (Mindi) is a huge white chocolate fan.
Fun Fact
White chocolate shows up in other Reeseās treats, including White Chocolate Miniatures and White Chocolate Thins.
8. Reeseās Nutrageous


Year Introduced: 1994
Reeseās Nutrageous fully embraces the almighty peanut. The chocolate-coated candy bar is jam-packed with both peanut butter and roasted peanuts as well as sweet caramel.
Our Take: Roasted peanuts give the Reeseās Nutrageous bar a crunch that the cups donāt provide. The nutty candy bar reminds us of Marsā Snickers bar.
Fun Fact
This candy bar was almost called Acclaim. Hershey switched to Nutrageous before its 1994 launch after focus groups (mostly kids) preferred the name.
9. Reeseās Dipped Pretzels


Year Introduced: 2017
More of a snack than a candy, Reeseās Dipped Pretzels flip the usual Reeseās formula by putting peanut butter on the outside instead of the center. The bottom of each crunchy pretzel is also coated with chocolate, and chocolate is drizzled in stripes on top.
Our Take: We like pretzels, we like chocolate and we like peanut butter. Yet, somehow, Reeseās Dipped Pretzels taste flat to us. Weād like them better if they were saltier or more chocolatey or both.
Fun Fact
Reeseās Dipped Pretzels arenāt the only dipped pretzels in the Hershey universe. The Pennsylvania candy company also sells Hersheyās Dipped Pretzels and Hersheyās Cookies ānā Creme Dipped Pretzels.
10. Reeseās Caramel Big Cup


Year Introduced: 2006
Year Reintroduced: 2023
Hershey elevated the Reeseās Big Cup concept when its candymakers inserted a layer of gooey caramel inside the jumbo peanut butter cup two decades ago. Theyāve since updated the formula to perfect that sweet, sticky layer.
Our Take: Caramel and peanut butter is a winning combo that we both appreciate, albeit in small doses.
Fun Fact
Caramel isnāt the only Big Cup flavor. Other Big Cup flavors include Chocolate Lava, Marshmallow and Strawberry PB&J.
11. Reeseās Chocolate Lava Big Cup


Year Introduced: 2024
Inspired by molten chocolate lava cake, Reeseās Chocolate Lava Big Cup adds an ooey-gooey chocolate layer to its expected peanut butter filling. That chocolate layer is relatively small, but its flavor takes center stage.
Our Take: Since weāre chocolate fans, we love this flavor. The lava layer is rich and fudgy without overshadowing the candyās signature peanut butter layer.
Fun Fact
French chef Michel Bras is credited with creating molten chocolate cake in 1981.
12. Reeseās Strawberry PB&J Big Cup


Year Introduced: 2025
Yet another twist on the Big Cup concept, Reeseās Strawberry PB&J Big Cup has a thin strawberry-flavored layer below its bigger peanut butter layer. Both layers are encased inside a milk chocolate coating.
Our Take: Something is missing for us in the Reeseās Strawberry PB&J Big Cup. We totally get that the combination of peanut butter and jelly is an iconic American sandwich filling. Weād probably like the candy version more if the jelly layer were flavored with actual fruit.
Fun Fact
Americans have been eating PB&J sandwiches for over a century. Hard-core fans celebrate National Peanut Butter and Jelly Day on April 2 every year.
13. Reeseās Peanut Butter Bar


A milk chocolate block bar filled with Reeseās peanut butter, the Reeseās Peanut Butter Bar is essentially a flat, portable version of the brandās peanut butter cup. Itās separated into 12 squares, which makes the bar easy to share. Not a fan of milk chocolate? The bar also comes in Caramel and White (see #14 below).
Our Take: At first glance, the Reeseās Peanut Butter Bar looks like a standard chocolate bar with 12 square sections. However, candy magic happens every time we bite into a square filled with sweet peanut butter. Yum!
Fun Fact
Each Reeseās Peanut Butter Bar square is embossed with a Reeseās Peanut Butter Cup design.
14. Reeseās White Peanut Butter Bar


Year Introduced: 2025
The Reeseās White Peanut Butter Bar is similar to the brandās original peanut butter bar with one exception: white chocolate takes the place of milk chocolate. Like the original bar, each square is molded in the shape of a Reeseās cup. Hershey launched the 90-gram bar in the UK in April 2025 and hasnāt yet announced a US launch date.
Our Take: This bar is sweet. The white chocolate amps up the sugar, so the salty peanut butter filling has to work harder to balance each bite. One of us (Mindi) is a fan. The other (Daryl) prefers the milk chocolate version. We both agree that it tastes better with a pinch of pink salt.
Fun Fact
White chocolate, which contains cocoa butter but no cocoa solids, dates back to the 1930s when NestlƩ introduced it in Switzerland.
15. Reeseās Marshmallow Big Cup


Year Introduced: 2007
Year Reintroduced: 2026
This Reeseās Marshmallow Big Cup pairs a thin marshmallow layer with a larger peanut butter layer. The resulting candy is reminiscent of a Fluffernutter minus the bread.
Our Take: The flavorās sweet, soft marshmallow layer overpowers its slightly salty peanut butter layer. One of us loves this flavor since sheās a marshmallow fan. The other, not so much.
Fun Fact
Reeseās first sold a marshmallow cup in 2007. The flavor disappeared for almost two decades before returning as a Big Cup in 2026.
š” Frequently Asked Questions
Reeseās is a popular Hershey candy that combines peanut butter and chocolate. The candy brand includes cups, bars, sticks, dipped pretzels and seasonal shapes.
H.B. Reese created Reeseās Peanut Butter Cups in 1928 in Hershey, Pennsylvania. The Hershey Company bought Reeseās company in 1963.
The Hershey Company has owned Reeseās since 1963.
No. Reeseās Pieces have a peanut butter center and a crunchy candy shell. Chocolate is not a Reeseās Pieces ingredient.
Reeseās Miniatures are small peanut butter cups individually wrapped in foil, which makes them great for Halloween trick-or-treaters. Reeseās Minis are even smaller and unwrapped, which makes them great for eating by the handful.
The Big Cup is a larger, thicker Reeseās cup with extra peanut butter. Hershey sells Big Cups in flavors that include Caramel, Chocolate Lava, Marshmallow and Strawberry PB&J.
Pretzels, caramel, peanuts, peanut butter and milk chocolate.
Our favorite is the Reeseās Peanut Butter Cup. Reeseās Take 5 is a close second. You need to taste them all to find your favorites.
š„ Video Recap
š¬ More Candy
š Pin This Article


āļø Disclosures
Article Updates
We update our articles regularly. Some updates are major, while others are minor link changes and spelling corrections. Let us know if you see anything that needs to be updated in this article.
Funding
We purchased and tasted the candy featured in this article. The Hershey Company did not sponsor or influence the ranking.






