With more than 20,000 restaurants in NYC, choosing where to eat in the Big Apple can be a serious challenge for visitors who want to eat it all. With eateries running the gamut from cheap eats to fine dining, the trick is finding truly great restaurants that fits your mood and budget.
Discover 11 great NYC restaurants where you can eat a special meal unless you’d rather eat burgers, pastrami sandwiches or bagels.
1. Katz’s Delicatessen
Katz’s is the holy grail when it comes to pastrami sandwich on rye. It’s a simple place where multiple service clerks slice meat by hand for each order. The clerks are nice if you behave but may get a little grouchy if you ask too many questions. Prices may seem high at first glance. However, the ginormous sandwiches are big enough to share though you may want to eat it all yourself.
Discover more great sandwiches in America and the world.
2. JG Melon
Located on an Upper East Side corner since 1972, JG Melon serves classic New York pub burgers made tasty with plenty of fat and served simply with a pickle on a generic white plate. Beyond burgers, other food highlights include chunky cottage fries and chocolate cake.
Discover more great burgers in NYC and beyond.
3. Keens Steakhouse
Keens Steakhouse has been serving steak to a cast of characters that includes Albert Einstein, Liza Minelli, J.P. Morgan, Babe Ruth and Doctor Ruth since the historic restaurant opened in 1885. The mutton chop is the dish to order here. It’s a tender, steak-like cut of lamb saddle that tastes great with minty lamb jus.
4. Russ & Daughters Cafe
A NYC institution since it opened in 1914, Russ & Daughters transcended from ‘just’ an appetizing store to restaurant status in 2014 when the cafe opened in the heart of the the Lower East Side. People queue for brunch all over the city but this one is special due to its boards topped with colorful assortments of smoked fish and accoutrements like capers, onions and tomatoes. Its blintzes and babka french toast are great too.
Discover the best bagel shops in NYC.
5. Manhatta
While it’s far from cheap, Manhatta is an affordable option for middle-end diners looking to splurge on a special meal and enjoy one of the city’s most spectacular views at the same time. Let’s face it – viewing the Brooklyn, Manhattan and Williamsburg Bridges while sipping a classic cocktail or slurping an oyster is a special thing. Following that with dishes like dry aged duck and foie gras pie makes for true event dining.
6. Joe’s Shanghai
Joe’s Shanghai represents a piece of New York history and its soup dumplings are made for Americans. Bite into a Joe’s dumpling and be prepared to slurp… a lot. Full of broth, the restaurant’s classic pork and crab dumplings are as satisfying as soup dumplings can be.
7. Barney Greengrass
Barney Greengrass has come a long way since the original Harlem appetizing store opened in 1908 and moved to the Upper West Side 21 years later which is where it is today. After more than a century, the self-annointed ‘sturgeon king’ deli continues to serve Jewish comfort foods like smoked and pickled fish, potato latkes, blintzes and babka.
8. S&P Lunch
The sky brightened and New Yorkers rejoiced when Eisenberg’s, a popular Flatiron lunch counter, re-opened in 2023. Now called S&P Lunch (the lunch counter’s original name back in 1928), much is the same including the restaurant’s long counter and its row of shabby-chic red vinyl stools. The same goes for menu items like the ever-popular tuna melt and egg cream.
9. Xi’an Famous Foods
The hand ripped noodles at Xi’an Famous Foods are rustic, filling and hugely flavorful. They’re served with a variety of toppings like cumin lamb, stewed pork and tingly beef. While the original Golden Mall location is now closed, you and we can slurp spicy dishes at a variety of stylish locations in Brooklyn, Manhattan and Queens. The noodles taste good in all three boroughs.
Discover more great Asian dishes.
10. L’Industrie Pizzeria
Originally opened in Williamsburg in 2017 when Massimo Laveglia acquired the French name along with a lease, L’Industrie uses premium ingredients like burrata, tartufo and fig jam to create slices that stand out in NYC’s buzzing pizza scene. It’s a pizza destination in a city filled with pizzerias. The same goes for the second L’Industrie in Manhattan.
Discover more great pizzerias in NYC.
11. Mariscos El Submarino
Intrepid foodies who venture to Jackson Heights in Queens will want to eat everything in the culturally diverse neighborhood. However, if you just have time for one meal, go to Mariscos El Submarino and eat aguachile and cóctel de camarón (i.e. Mexican shrimp cocktail). Be sure to sip a spicy michelado cocktail too.
Read Next: New York Food Favorites
Now that you know where to eat in NYC, discover what to eat while you explore the city that never sleeps.
More Great Restaurants
Since food is the best part of travel, don’t miss these restaurants when you travel to Barcelona, Paris and Rome:
About the Authors
Daryl and Mindi Hirsch
Saveur Magazine’s BEST TRAVEL BLOG award winners Daryl and Mindi Hirsch share their culinary travel experiences and recipes on the 2foodtrippers website. Since launching the site in 2012, they’ve traveled to over 40 countries in their quest to bring readers a unique taste of the world.